What are the best tomatoes for pizza sauce?

Pizza sauce is a quick and flavorful addition to any meal, especially pizza. It’s easy to use and delicious! But too many pizza sauces are watery, with nobody or character. This is why people ask for the best pizza sauce and the best tomatoes for pizza sauce.

The best tomato for pizza sauce is San Marzano tomatoes. Neapolitan pizza makers say that it is not just the variety of tomatoes but the terroir, soil, and climate that make the difference.

Furthermore, they come from the San Marzano Valley in Italy, famous for its rich, flavorful tomatoes. Their thick skin and few seeds make them perfect for canned tomatoes.

You can find these tomatoes canned whole or chopped, but they’re harder to find fresh. Canned San Marzano tomatoes are used in many of the popular tomato sauces you see on the market today.

What are the best tomatoes for pizza sauce

How to make pizza sauce with tomato paste?

You can make a tasty pizza sauce with tomato paste in just a minute or two. And the best part is this basic sauce can be used in numerous ways, including topping a pizza or as a sauce for cooked pasta.

You will need onion, basil, tomato paste, and garlic cloves.

  • First, saute the chopped onions over medium heat for about 10 minutes adding 1 to 2 tbsp of water.

Next, · Add the tomato paste, minced garlic, and dried basil and mix for another 5 minutes.

  • Add the can of crushed tomatoes, Worcestershire sauce, salt, and pepper and let it cook for 15 more minutes.

Can you use any tomato sauce for pizza?

You can use any tomato sauce for a pizza base, but you might find that you prefer the taste of a particular one for a pizza. I like to use pizza sauce (tomato, basil, and garlic) as it gives a delicious, full flavor.

Also, it depends on how picky you are. Pizza sauce has oregano, garlic, and onion or garlic powder in it, just to make it taste better with cheeses and bread. Tomato purée (plain tomato sauce) tastes just as good.

In addition, for the best taste, use Pizza Sauce. It is made exclusively for pizza and calzones. It is thicker than tomato sauce because pizza and calzones are baked after being assembled.

Best tomatoes for pizza sauce

Here is a list of tomato varieties and the use for each variety in the kitchen.

  • Cherry tomatoes

Cherry tomatoes are smaller round tomatoes that typically have a sweet flavor. However, they burst with flavor and add a nice sweetness and brightness that typical canned tomatoes don’t.

Because of the intense flavor and low acidity, the Cherry Tomato has proven to be an excellent ingredient for many tomato sauces, especially pizza sauces where a bold sauce is required. However, some have a lot more seeds and juice.

  • Plum tomatoes

Plum tomatoes have a great flavor and meaty texture that is perfect for cooking down into a rich sauce in pizza, pasta, or casserole recipes. They are grown especially for their taste and versatility in creating sauces.

Plum tomatoes are great for making pizza sauce because they have less water than other tomatoes and are more dense and meaty, with fewer seed cavities. When cooking, plum tomatoes also break down more easily than other varieties.

  • Grape tomatoes

Grape tomatoes will work for pizza sauce. Grape tomatoes have a good amount of tomato flavor, which is ideal for making pizza sauce for pizzas, or any dish you want to add as a topping.

However, for a pizza sauce, you should probably use crushed tomatoes. Blend the tomatoes with the rest of the pizza-sauce ingredients.

  • Roma tomatoes

Roma tomatoes are very versatile and can be used for a great variety of culinary purposes. They are one of the best tomatoes for a sauce because of their high concentration of flesh, low moisture content, right thickness, and texture which can be made into a thicker sauce than other tomato varieties.

They are a preferred option for homemade pasta sauces or pizza. Roma fruits are meaty, low in moisture, and contain just 2 to 3 seeds.

  • Beefsteak tomatoes

Beefsteak tomatoes are a large variety of tomatoes. They can weigh in at about a pound, and some may even be two or three pounds. Beefsteak tomatoes are popular for a good reason. Their size is just right for pizza, and they’re rich with flavor. They will give your pizza a nice bold flavor.

  • Heirloom tomatoes

Heirloom tomatoes are grown for their taste, not their ability to survive shipping. The result is a richer, more flavorful tomato with high acidity. In addition, heirloom tomatoes have a lot of natural sugar content (where you’ll get the sweet/tart balance).

There is more retained flavor because they are not packed together in canning factories like many other sauce recipes. This makes Heirloom tomatoes great for making pizza sauce.

  • Tomatoes on the vine

Tomatoes on the vine are a type of tomato that has been carefully selected for vine ripening (growing to their peak flavor) before harvesting. They’re left on the vine more than in the usual commercial picking of tomatoes to allow them to ripen and develop more concentrated flavors.

Tomatoes on the vine don’t necessarily have any more intense tomato taste than other tomatoes, but they do tend to be sweeter.

So if you use them for a sauce, you might want to add something with a complimentary fruity bite of acidities, such as basil or red wine vinegar.

  • Green tomatoes

Green tomatoes are unripe tomatoes, naturally more sour than ripe red tomatoes. This makes them the best ingredient to use when you’re making a savory, rich pizza sauce that tastes as delicious as it smells.

Green tomatoes will give you a great flavor, but it may take longer to cook the sauce. The reason is that green tomatoes contain tannins, an astringent substance.

  • Italian tomatoes

Italian tomatoes (also known as paste tomatoes) have the right combination of low moisture, mild flavor, and thicker flesh. All of these characteristics make them ideal for cooking down into a thick and flavorful sauce.

In addition, Italian tomatoes are some of the best in the world, prized for their flavor and versatility. They’re perfect for any kind of sauce, whether it’s tomato sauce or Alfredo sauce, as well as many recipes like soups, pasta, and stews.

What are the best tomatoes for pizza sauce

What tomatoes are best for homemade sauce?

The best tomatoes for homemade sauce boast a combination of tartness and sweetness, have meaty flesh, and have minimal seeds.

Ideally, the tomatoes you choose will be the ripest available. For example, the Roma tomato is ideal for a thick, rich tomato sauce for pizzas because of its high ratio of flesh to juice.

Roma variety, also called plum tomatoes,, has a good balance of sweetness and tartness to make a delicious sauce.

They have the right consistency, which is thicker than other varieties of tomatoes. They’re also cheap and easy to find at grocery stores.

In addition, San Marzano tomatoes are also one of the best tomatoes for making sauce. With the high salt content of the sauce, regular tomatoes may not break down as easily and may result in a watery sauce.

San Marzano tomatoes are sweeter and meatier than other tomatoes, which means they add flavor and body to the sauce; their high acidity helps to keep it from getting overly sweet.

Why are San Marzano tomatoes used for pizza?

There are three main reasons why San Marzano tomatoes are used to make pizza sauce: thin skin, low acidity, and high sugar content.

The extremely thin skin of San Marzano tomatoes makes them easy to crush by hand and also helps them maintain their shape while being tossed in the air during tossing. These same properties make this type of tomato ideal for achieving perfect consistency when cooking.

Also, their low-acid content is perfect for pizza sauce because it makes the tomatoes less bitter. They have a sweet yet rich flavor that helps balance out the bold cheese flavors used in pizza toppings, enhancing the overall taste of the pie.

Here’s one last surprising fact about San Marzano tomatoes. They are not grown commercially anymore. But don’t worry, there are plenty left to make a sauce with because most people don’t realize that these tasty fruits come from vines that grow inside tunnels or caves rather than outside gardens.

What is the difference between Roma and San Marzano tomatoes?

Roma tomatoes and San Marzano tomatoes are both plum or paste but San Marzano is Roma. The San Marzano tomato is a cross between Roma tomatoes and wild Peruvian tomatoes.

Unlike the teardrop shape of the Roma tomato, the San Marzano is slightly longer (between 5 and 6 inches). The flesh is also thinner than that of the Roma.

Another difference between the two varieties is where they are grown, their size, taste, and acidity. Roma tomatoes grow in the USA. The fruit has a lower acid level, a meaty texture, and few seeds. San Marzano tomatoes grow in Italy, near the town of San Marzano Sul Sarno.

These stalky plants produce small pear-shaped red fruit that has a sharper flavor than Roma tomatoes. Both fruits have relatively small cores and very few seeds, making them ideal for use in sauces and pastes.

Do you have to peel Roma tomatoes for sauce?

No, you don’t have to peel Roma tomatoes before use. The tomatoes are cooked down and become soft to break down during the cooking process. They make a smooth sauce when blended, and the skins are soft.

However, you can peel them if you want to. You can use a food processor to quickly and easily remove the skins by placing the tomatoes into the food processor with a little water, then pulsing until the water is red with tomato flesh and the tomato skins are mostly floating. Strain out the skins, and you’re left with a lumpy sauce that needs to be simmered down.

What are the best tomatoes for pizza sauce

What tomatoes do Italians use for pizza?

In Italy, they only use San Marzano tomatoes. They’re hand-selected, never pre-cooked, and grown by one family of farmers since 1929 on the volcanic plains outside Naples.

The rich soil, plentiful sunshine, and cool Mediterranean Sea breezes (that’s “mistral” in Italian) give these special tomatoes a sweeter flavor than other varieties.

In addition, a few simple ingredients, including sea salt and basil, are cooked together to create a traditional red pizza sauce with a bold, savory flavor and the perfect balance of acidity and sweetness.

Do Italians put tomatoes on pizza?

Tomatoes are a staple among Italians. On average, an Italian consumes 33 pounds of tomatoes per year! So, yes. Italians put tomatoes on pizza.

Also, a pizza without tomato sauce is like a Christmas tree without lights. You can still see it but not as bright. It’s creamy yet tangy with the right balance of herbs and spices to elevate your pies, pasta, and beyond.

Does Margherita pizza have sliced tomatoes?

Margherita pizza is traditionally topped with tomatoes, sliced mozzarella, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil.

Also, it has sliced tomatoes that are seasoned with a little basil, salt, and pepper. Some like to add extra cheese on top.

What canned tomatoes to use for pizza?

Ultimately, you should go with the San Marzano tomatoes that have the longest fermentation period. This means less time in a can and more time getting ripe on a plant before being picked and canned.

Other tomato varieties like DOP, a San Marzano variety (the “DOP” designation means that these San Marzanos are certified according to strict growing and handling standards), or even plum tomatoes (Pomodoro San Marzano dell’Agro Sarnese-Nocerino), which will also give you a strong tomato flavor.

Is Marinara good for pizza?

Marinara sauce is the “classic” pizza sauce. It’s used for simple pizza Margherita and all kinds of other pizzas. Marinara is a thick, simple tomato sauce that contains only a few ingredients.

This style of pizza sauce is best used on simpler or thinner pizza dough, as it won’t add too much additional moisture to the pizza.

Marinara is a fresh tomato sauce made from tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, and herbs like oregano and basil. A rich marinara sauce is often used on pizza.

A simple marinara sauce will do well with a thin crust and mozzarella, but it also goes well with more delicate toppings like ricotta and arugula.

What are the best tomatoes for pizza sauce

Can passata be used as pizza base?

Absolutely. You can use passata on the base of your pizza. You can also add a touch of cream, tomato paste, and herbs to your passata to make the perfect pizza sauce.

In addition, Passata is a great option for pizza sauce. The smooth, sieve-like consistency of passata makes it perfect for a thin and even layer across the pizza base.

Is tomato sauce the same as pizza sauce?

Not quite. While they certainly look similar, they have their differences, and you can use both on your pizza.

The term “pizza sauce” is used somewhat interchangeably with “tomato sauce” when it’s a specific type of tomato sauce that differs in ingredients, consistency, and flavor from most other tomato sauces (such as marinara or arrabbiata). So what makes it different?

Pizza sauce is specifically made to give your pie its rich flavor. On the other hand, tomato sauce is meant to be used with pasta or base for other dishes.

As a sauce, pizza sauce is more of a basic tomato sauce than a marinara. It is not designed for use on its own but as an ingredient in another dish.

If you want it to be more flavorful, you will probably cook it with meat and other pizza toppings. Also, it depends on the brand of pizza sauce you get.

Why is tomato called Pomodoro in Italian?

You have ever wondered how this sweet red fruit got its Italian name, pomodoro? It’s an anglicization of the Italian for the apple of gold. In other words, it’s a gilded tomato.

Furthermore, the word Pomodoro itself is thought to have been coined in Naples in 1596 and was eventually adapted into English by 1652 as “tomato.”

In 1759, Swedish naturalist Carl Linnaeus shortened it further to tomato, a name that became firmly established with Heinz opening its first tomato ketchup factory in 1927.

How do you keep tomatoes from getting soggy on a pizza?

A soupy pizza can be tricky to manage, and when it comes to pizza Margherita, you’re after gooey cheese and flavorful, uncooked sauce. However, we have the secret to keeping your tomato sauce from becoming soggy pizza.

Just cook your tomatoes on low flame for a few minutes to drive off the water before putting it on top of your pizza.

  • Start with a flavorful slow-cooked tomato sauce with a slightly sweet taste and bright color.
  • Next, add the perfect blend of spices; oregano, onion, garlic, and salt, which bring out the tomato flavor without overpowering it.
  • The result is a smooth, deliciously flavored pizza sauce that will be the ideal base for your next homemade pie.

Should I cook tomatoes before putting on pizza?

There are many schools on whether tomatoes need to be cooked before using on a pizza. The traditional Neapolitan-style pizza requires the tomatoes to be uncooked. But, you can cook them if you prefer. ​It’s simple: Slice the tomatoes in half and place cut-side down on a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper or nonstick foil. Bake at 175 degrees for 20 minutes, cool, then use on your pizza.

In addition, cooking the sauce on or off the pie doesn’t matter; you want to concentrate the flavor by cooking off most of the water, making a sauce bland or watery.


The best tomatoes for pizza sauce eventually come down to personal preference. It’s just like choosing the right flour, the right oven set up, or getting the right stretch or sludge for your dough; it all depends on what works for you.

However, if you want to choose one based on the recommendation of pizza makers, the San Marzano is the best tomato for pizza sauce.

Leave a Comment